04

Difficult Decisions

Tell them I wasn't a coward. If anyone asks.

Private Mikkelsen, to Erik Solberg

“They’re accelerating the timeline.”

Blackwood’s words cut through the predawn stillness as I helped load communication equipment onto one of the trucks bound for the harbour. His uniform was impeccable again — the creases back, the buttons right — as though he had reclaimed something of himself in preparation for what was coming. The officer who had sat with me on the overlook two days ago, visibly carrying the weight of what he was doing, had been replaced by the version of himself that could do it.

“The evacuation?” I asked, though I already knew.

He nodded. “Intelligence reports suggest the Germans know we’re pulling out. They’re mobilising to cut off the harbour. We move tonight instead of tomorrow.”

I set down the radio equipment. “That leaves no time for the lottery.”

“The decision has been made at higher levels. Essential personnel only.” He paused, not meeting my eyes. “You should come with us, Solberg. Your language skills would be valuable in coordinating future operations.”

There it was. The offer I had both expected and dreaded, arriving with the brisk practicality of a man who had cleared his conscience by framing it as operational rather than personal.

“And my men? Kristian? Dahl?”

“I can’t make promises for anyone else.”

I had already made my decision on the ridge two nights ago. I had gone to find Kristian afterwards, and he had simply nodded, as though he had known, and that had been that. But hearing the offer spoken aloud produced its own specific gravity.

“I appreciate the offer, Captain,” I said. “But my place is here.”

Something settled in his expression — not surprise, but a kind of completion, as though this answer had been the one he had expected and the formality of the question had simply been required. He extended his hand. “It’s been an honour, Corporal Solberg.”

“Likewise, Captain.”

His truck pulled away toward the harbour. I watched it go until the tree line took it, and then I went to find Haugen.


The briefing was short. Norwegian officers only, gathered around Haugen’s map in the grey predawn light, their faces carrying the specific look of men adjusting to a situation they have accepted rather than one they have made peace with. The distinction mattered.

Rear guard. Hold the position through the evacuation. Allow the British ships to clear the fjord. Then fall back to the prepared positions in the mountains.

Dahl received these orders without visible reaction, which was how Dahl received everything. He studied the map for a moment after Haugen finished. “Contact timeline,” he said.

“German forward units should reach the southern approach by sixteen hundred at the earliest. The harbour should be clear by fourteen hundred. There will be a gap.” Haugen paused. “Or there should be.”

There were no further questions.


The hours between the briefing and the first German contact were the longest I had spent in this war that did not involve immediate danger.

This was worse than immediate danger. Immediate danger occupied the hands and the eyes and the reflexes and left nowhere for thought to accumulate. Waiting left too much room. The men filled it the way soldiers always fill it — with the small tasks of maintenance and preparation, the repetitive motions of men who need something to do with their hands while their minds work over things they cannot stop working over.

Kristian cleaned his rifle. I had watched him clean it more times than I could count over the past weeks, and the motion had become something close to meditative for him — bolt out, patches through the barrel, oil on the working parts, the satisfaction of moving mechanisms that moved the way they were supposed to move. He was not a man who found waiting easy, and this was how he made it bearable.

Johansen sat with his back against a tree and worked on a letter. He had been writing the same letter, or variations of it, for three days. I had not asked who it was to. Some things were private in a way that became more private the more precarious the situation.

Mikkelsen, who was the youngest of us at twenty, sharpened his knife on a whetstone he had been carrying since the first day, though the knife had not needed sharpening for at least a week. The sound of it — that specific high patient scraping — was its own kind of reassurance.

“What do you think it’s like?” Mikkelsen asked at some point. Not to anyone in particular.

“What what’s like?” Kristian said, without looking up.

“Surrendering. Laying your rifle down. What does that feel like.”

Nobody answered immediately. It was not the kind of question that wanted an immediate answer.

“My father surrendered in 1918,” Dahl said, from where he was sitting on a log with his coffee. “He said it felt like putting down something you’d been carrying so long you’d forgotten it had weight.” A pause. “He also said the walk home took most of a year and was the worst part of the war.”

“He got home though,” Mikkelsen said.

“He got home.”

Mikkelsen returned to his knife.

Kristian looked up at me across the fire. He had the expression he sometimes got in the café in Narvik — that particular Kristian look of having thought about something until he reached the part of it that was worth saying, and then deciding to say it. “We should have a drink when this is over,” he said. “In Andersen’s. Back table.”

“We don’t have to wait until it’s over,” I said.

“No, but it’ll mean more then.” He nodded to himself, as though having arrived at a satisfying conclusion. “We’ll sit in the back and Andersen will bring the good stuff out of the back, not the stuff he gives to people he doesn’t know, and we’ll drink it and not talk about any of this.”

“Not talk about any of what?”

“Exactly.”

Johansen folded his letter and put it in his breast pocket. He looked across at us. “Can I come?”

“Of course you can come,” Kristian said, and Johansen looked briefly younger than he was, and then returned to looking the way he had been looking all morning.

We waited.


Private Cooper found me as I was setting up the machine gun nest overlooking the main road.

“Thought you’d be gone by now,” I said, and heard the edge in my own voice.

“Shipping out in an hour.” He shifted his weight, looked at the gun, looked at me. He had the manner of a man who has something to say and is trying to find the version of it that doesn’t sound like an excuse. “Listen, Solberg. This isn’t right. What we’re doing.”

“Following orders is never wrong, isn’t that what they teach you?”

“That’s not—” He stopped. Frustrated, brief. Then he thrust a small package wrapped in oilcloth into my hands. “Extra ammunition for that Krag. And chocolate. My mum sent it.” He paused. “The stuff I brought over to your fire, the first week. Same batch.”

The same chocolate his mother had sent that Kristian had eaten with such deliberate neutrality. I looked up at him — this young British soldier, genuinely troubled by something he had no power to change. His expression was not the expression of a man doing a performatively decent thing. He was, I thought, exactly what he appeared to be: a person who felt things and did not know what to do with the feeling when the thing causing it was larger than him.

“Thank you,” I said. The bitterness went out of me.

“We’ll be back,” he said, with the earnest certainty that belonged to his age and that the war had not yet finished taking from him. “Britain won’t abandon Norway forever. You have my word.”

We both understood what a private’s word was worth in the calculations of generals and politicians. I shook his hand anyway.

“Stay alive, Cooper.”

“You too.” The brief honest smile. “I still owe you that tour.”

I watched him walk back toward the harbour road. He did not look back, which I thought was a deliberate choice rather than an absence of feeling.


As evening came on, the last British ships prepared to depart.

From my position on the hillside I watched the boarding. Orderly lines of men carrying what they could, leaving behind what they could not. Blackwood was somewhere in it — I had last seen him at the command tent, the officer version of himself fully restored, directing the final phase of withdrawal with the precise efficiency I had come to expect from him. He had not looked for me and I had not looked for him, and I thought that was probably right.

The ships moved slowly at first, easing out of the harbour into the main channel of the fjord. The light was going, the sky to the west still holding a faint copper at the horizon, the water darker below it. I could see the shapes of the vessels distinctly at first — the transport ships, the naval escort, the smaller support craft — and then less distinctly, as the distance and the failing light worked on them together.

I thought of all the things I might think about watching them go. The betrayal, which was real and which I had largely worked through already on the ridge two nights ago. The calculation that had been made in London about what Norway was worth relative to France, which was a reasonable calculation by certain measures and which I found I could not argue with abstractly and could not accept personally and was going to have to carry both of those things at once. Blackwood’s face on the overlook, the cost briefly showing. Cooper’s earnest certainty.

I thought about the men beside me on this hillside. Kristian, cleaning his rifle again, the motion so familiar now it was like watching him breathe. Dahl, standing a short distance away, watching the ships with no expression that I could identify. Johansen, who had finally finished his letter and posted it with the last outgoing mail before the communications unit packed up, and who now sat with his hands loose in his lap in the way of a man who has set something down and has not yet decided what to pick up next.

These men had made the same choice I had, through whatever different reasoning, and were here on this hillside making it real.

The ships grew smaller.

I had lived my whole life on the edge of this fjord. I had been on the water most of my life, in my father’s boat and before that in the small dinghy he had taught me to handle, learning the way the water moved and the way the wind came off the mountains and the particular colours the fjord took at different times of year. I knew this water. I had measured myself against it since I was old enough to go out on it.

The British lights on the water grew smaller until they were indistinguishable from the stars beginning to show in the darkening sky above, and then I could not find them at all, and then they were simply gone.

Our allies were gone. We were alone.

From somewhere below, the first German mortar shell landed near the harbour.


The fighting that night was the sharpest we had faced.

The Germans came with the confidence of men who knew the opposition was reduced and the clock was with them. They were not wrong about either thing. What they had not accounted for was the ground — the same advantage we had held for three weeks, the ridgelines and the approaches that we knew in the dark from weeks of standing watch on them, the positions Haugen had prepared and that Blackwood had been diplomatically presented with as a joint decision.

Haugen’s voice on the radio was steady throughout, giving positions and redirecting fire with the calm efficiency of a man who had been preparing for exactly this.

“Fall back to position two. Repeat, fall back to position two.”

I signalled my squad — five men where once we had been twelve — and we began the withdrawal, laying covering fire for each other as we moved up the hillside. A mortar shell exploded twenty metres to my right and sent Kristian sprawling. I reached him before I had consciously decided to move.

“I’m fine,” he said immediately, already getting an arm under himself, though blood was darkening his uniform. “Shrapnel. Nothing vital.”

I helped him up and we continued. Ahead, Dahl was keeping the Madsen working, laying down suppressing fire in the controlled bursts I had come to recognise as his signature — not wasteful, not cautious, exactly what the situation required and no more.

We reached the stone farmhouse at the secondary position just as Haugen was organising the next phase. His face was briefly lit by a flare overhead — sharp, clear lines, the particular look of a man operating without margin.

“They’re pushing harder than expected. There’s a civilian evacuation on the north road — families, old people, they’re not moving fast enough. We need to buy more time.” He looked at me. “Solberg — take two men and secure the eastern approach. If they flank us there, we’re done.”

Kristian was already at my side.

“Don’t argue,” he said. “I can still shoot.”

The wound had darkened a larger area of his uniform than I liked. “Kristian—”

“I can still shoot, Erik.” Steady. Definite.

Johansen fell in without being asked, the rifle easy across his shoulders, his face set.

We moved to the rocky outcrop overlooking the eastern slope in the dark and settled into position. The trees below us were still, and then they were not.

The first German scouts appeared at the edge of the tree line, moving carefully in the way of men who knew they were advancing against a position and were not certain of the opposition. I could make out the shapes of helmets through my scope.

“Wait for my signal,” I said. “Let them get closer.”

Kristian tensed. Johansen breathed steadily beside me.

At a hundred metres I fired. The front man crumpled. Kristian and Johansen opened up immediately, and for several minutes we held the slope — the elevation, the prepared positions, the knowledge of exactly where the ground dropped and where it levelled all doing the work that numbers could not.

Then the MG34 opened up. Positioned behind a fallen tree, firing in the controlled chattering bursts that meant a trained crew, far heavier than our aging Madsens. Rounds chipped the rock around us and forced us flat.

“That gun has to go,” I said.

Kristian looked at the position — the angle, the cover available, the ground between. I could see him calculating. “I’ll go left. Draw their fire. You take right, get an angle.”

“Kristian—”

He was already moving, keeping low but not low enough to be invisible, the deliberate visibility of a man offering himself as bait and knowing it. The MG34 swung toward him. He threw himself behind a boulder and I moved — cover to cover, each position a calculation, working rightward until I had a clean line on the German emplacement.

Two men on the gun. A third providing security, watching the flanks. I steadied, exhaled, and put three rounds down in quick succession — the gunner, the loader, and then I was already shifting and the third man was returning fire wildly into the wrong position until Johansen’s shot, clean and measured, ended it.

Silence.

I signalled across to Kristian’s boulder. He emerged, giving me the grim satisfied look I had known since we were boys — the look that said that worked without saying anything so undignified as that.

The sniper’s bullet took him in the chest.

He went down without a sound, which was wrong — Kristian had never in his life done anything without some accompanying noise — and the wrongness of the silence was the first thing that reached me, before the understanding reached me, before any of it reached me. I was running before I had processed what I was running toward.

Then I was beside him, and the blood coming through his jacket was too dark and too fast.

“Medic.” The word was useless. The nearest medic was three hundred metres away and there was fire between us. “Johansen — cover us.”

I got him behind the boulder and pressed my hands against the wound, tearing strips from my shirt, pressing hard, my hands slick. He looked up at me with the specific expression of a man who has received information and is assessing it honestly.

“Don’t be dramatic,” he said. Each word cost him something. “It’s not that bad.”

We both knew exactly how bad it was.

“Stay with me,” I said. “Just stay with me.”

He gripped my wrist. His hand was still strong — still the grip of the man who had lifted me out of the fjord when I was seven years old — and that strength felt like a lie that his body was telling and could not keep telling for long.

“Listen.” He had to work for the word. “You need to continue. When I’m gone. Fight for Norway.”

“We’ll fight together,” I said. “Like we promised.”

A ghost of a smile. “Always were stubborn.”

His hand slackened. His eyes went to the sky, to whatever the sky was in that moment, and then they were still.

I stayed for a moment that lasted considerably longer than it was. My childhood friend. The boy who had decided we were friends when we were seven and had not asked for my agreement on the matter. The man who had stood beside me in every fight since the first morning of the invasion, who had been there in Andersen’s café when the radio interrupted the morning programme, who had rubbed the back of his neck and said we’re going to fight in the same level voice he might have used to propose anything.

Johansen’s hand found my shoulder. “Corporal. They’re coming again.”

I took a breath. “Get his ammunition. And his grenades.”

We held the eastern approach for three more hours. Two men instead of three, rotating positions constantly to suggest numbers we did not have, using the ground the way we had learned to use it. When the withdrawal order came, I carried Kristian over my shoulder. He was not light. I was aware of this the way you are aware of things that do not matter and that you carry anyway.

I would not leave him to be buried by German hands in unmarked ground.


Haugen met us at the logging camp perimeter in the dark. He took in what I was carrying and his face registered brief surprise, then the grim compression of a man receiving difficult information he was expecting eventually.

“The civilian evacuation is complete,” he said. “Your action on the eastern approach bought them the time they needed.”

“Permission to bury him properly, sir.”

“Granted. Take what time you need.” He paused. “He was a good soldier, Solberg. One of the best I’ve had.”

I dug the grave at dawn in the hard Norwegian soil. The ground was still partially frozen below the surface and the digging was slow and the slowness was its own kind of time, the physical effort taking up the space in me that would otherwise have had nowhere to go. Dahl appeared partway through and dug without speaking until the grave was deep enough, and then stepped back and let me finish.

I marked it with a wooden cross — his name, the date. Nothing else. No rank, no regiment, no war. Just Kristian Olsen, returned to his own earth. I had tried to think of something to say and had not found anything. The things I wanted to say were not the kind of things that became words easily — seventeen years of knowing someone, of being known by them, the way he had mimed the explosion with his hands and rubbed the back of his neck when he was thinking and told me things I did not want to hear with enough directness that I could not pretend not to have heard them. None of it condensed into language.

So I stood over the grave in silence, which was probably what he would have preferred anyway. Kristian had been suspicious of speeches.

The fjord was visible from where I stood. Grey in the morning light, still and quiet in the way it was always quiet, indifferent to everything on its banks. Somewhere below its surface, the Blücher was still there — that eight thousand tonnes of German certainty that the Oscarsborg guns had dealt with in a single April morning. Kristian had laughed telling me about it. He had mimed the explosion with both hands and then rubbed them together and said a thousand Germans taking an April swim with the brief satisfied grin he reserved for things that had gone right.

He had been right about most things, in the end. The British. The arithmetic of the war. The question of what we owed the country we were standing on.

Dahl put his hand briefly on my shoulder and then took it away. He did not say anything. He turned and walked back toward the camp.

I stayed a moment longer.


Haugen found me still at the grave.

He came alone, which was unusual — Haugen almost always had someone in his orbit, an officer or a runner or a situation requiring his attention. Coming alone, at this hour, to this particular place, told me before he spoke that what he was carrying was not operational.

“Corporal Solberg.” His voice was low. “Norwegian high command has officially surrendered to German forces. We are ordered to lay down our arms.”

The words were not a surprise. I had been expecting something like them since the night on the ridge with the Northern Lights, since the ships disappearing into the dark of the fjord. That did not make them land any differently.

“When, sir?”

“The order was issued two hours ago. By noon, any soldier still bearing arms will be considered a combatant outside the terms of surrender. The legal protections of the Geneva Convention will no longer apply.” He gave this information in the same level voice he used for position reports and fire directives — the voice he had developed, I thought, precisely because men in his position needed to be able to say difficult things without the weight of their own feeling making those things harder than they already were.

He looked at the grave. His expression shifted — something moved across it briefly, not the controlled professional face but the other one, the face of the man it cost something to be who he was. It was only for a moment. Then the control was back.

“Come,” he said.


The remaining men had gathered at the logging camp perimeter without needing to be called, drawn by some collective awareness that something was being said that needed to be heard. Twelve men, where once there had been thirty. They stood in the morning cold with their rifles and their weeks of accumulated weariness, faces I had been looking at for so long that I knew each one the way you know a landscape you have moved through in all weathers.

Haugen stood before them. He looked at each face in turn, briefly, with the precision of a man conducting an inventory of something that mattered.

“Norwegian high command has officially surrendered,” he said. “We are ordered to lay down our arms. Those who comply will be treated as prisoners of war under the Geneva Convention. Transportation to a collection point will be arranged from the main road. You have until noon.”

He paused. The silence was the specific silence of men who have received information of great magnitude and are not yet ready to speak.

“Those who make other choices should be in the eastern forest by dusk.” He looked at the trees. Then back at the men. “I can say no more than that.”

He did not walk away. He stood. He let the silence be what it was. The responsibility he felt toward these men — toward the choice each of them was now required to make — was visible in the way he stood there and absorbed the weight of it rather than distributing it and moving on.

Then he nodded once, to no one in particular, and walked to the edge of the clearing and stood with his back partly to the men, looking at the trees. Not dismissing them. Just making space.

Nobody spoke immediately. The words settled like sediment, finding their level in each man according to what he had and what he owed and what he was capable of.

Mikkelsen was the first to move. He sat down on a log — the sit of a man whose legs had made a decision before his mind caught up — and looked at his rifle across his knees, and then looked at nothing in particular.

I watched him. He was twenty years old. He had joined in April with the same insufficient understanding that all of us had had, and he had learned what we all had learned, and he was sitting on this log with a calculation to make that no twenty-year-old should be required to make alone.

He looked up and found me looking at him.

“My mother is in Tromsø,” he said. Not an explanation. A fact, offered.

“I know,” I said.

“My father is dead. It’s just us.” He looked back at his rifle. “If I’m taken prisoner, she knows where I am. If I go into the forest…” He did not finish.

I sat down beside him. The cold was in the trees and in the ground and in the specific quality of the morning light.

“It’s the right choice,” I said. “For you.”

He had the expression of a young man who needs permission he knows he should not need. “You think so?”

“I think you know what you owe your mother. That’s not a small thing.”

“What about Norway?”

“Norway will still need people after this is over. People who survived.” I looked toward the grave visible between the trees. “Not everyone can stay. Not everyone should.”

He nodded slowly. He picked up his rifle and held it for a long moment — the rifle he had carried since April, cleaned and maintained through everything — and then he leaned it with care against the log and stood up. The care was the thing that stayed with me. As though it deserved a proper resting place. As though the leaving of it was something to be done with respect.

“Tell them I wasn’t a coward,” he said. “If anyone asks.”

“You weren’t,” I said. “Not even close.”

He walked toward the main road. He did not look back.

Others followed over the next hour. Berg, who said nothing to anyone and simply walked. Two men from Haugen’s original platoon. Each made his calculation in his own way, and each walked with the particular quietness of men trying not to draw attention to a decision they had already committed to.

By the time the hour was done, six had gone to the road. Six remained.

Dahl moved to stand beside me. “I’m too old to start following German orders,” he said.

“You’re not that old,” I said.

“Old enough.”

Johansen was already there. He had posted his letter, done the only useful thing available to him in that regard, and here he was. Haugen stood apart, watching the men who remained, counting them in the way he counted everything — precisely, without sentiment, establishing what he had to work with.

Three other men I had been fighting alongside for weeks: Lunde, who had a wife and children and had chosen this anyway; Bergmann, who had not spoken about his reasons and would not; and Pettersen, who was a schoolteacher from Ålesund and had the kind of stubborn quiet that schoolteachers sometimes had.

Nine men. Where once we had been thirty.

I shouldered my Krag-Jørgensen. The rifle was old and scarred and familiar in a way that had passed beyond mere instrument and had become something else — part of the inventory of my own body, as much a part of how I moved through the world as my own hands.

The eastern forest was dark and dense and had been Norwegian for longer than anyone in it could account for.

As dusk fell I walked toward it. Behind me was Kristian’s grave and the uniforms and ranks and protocols of the Norwegian Army and the particular version of the fight that had ended today. Ahead was the other kind.

But also resistance.

For now, that was enough.